The prospect of visible scarring, post-operative pain and extended recovery can be daunting, particularly for women who are also navigating a cancer diagnosis.
A surgical technique known as vNOTES (vaginal Natural Orifice Transluminal Endoscopic Surgery) offers an alternative approach. Leaving no visible scar with minimal blood loss, it is performed through a small cut in the vagina using laparoscopic instruments, and provides faster recovery compared to conventional surgery.
KKH Special Delivery speaks with Dr Ravichandran Nadarajah, Head and Senior Consultant, Department of Gynaecological Oncology, KKH, about vNOTES, and what it means for women and referring clinicians.
Q: What can vNOTES be used for?
Dr Ravichandran: vNOTES can be used for common to complex procedures such as hysterectomy, removal of fallopian tubes and ovaries, ovarian cyst removal, and advanced urogynaecological and gynae-oncological surgeries. KKH is one of the first hospitals in Singapore to offer this surgical option since 2021.
Q: In what types of patients might vNOTES be particularly beneficial?
Dr Ravichandran: vNOTES offers significant benefits across a wide range of patients, and the evidence supporting its advantages is strong.
Several groups stand to benefit most:
Beyond clinical benefits, vNOTES is also cost-effective, making it a compelling option not just for patients but from a broader healthcare perspective as well.
Q: Is vNOTES better than conventional surgical approaches?
Dr Ravichandran: Based on available evidence, vNOTES compares favourably against open surgery and minimally invasive approaches. At KKH, we consider it the preferred method and an emerging standard of care, particularly in managing gynaecological cancers.
The advantages of vNOTES stem largely from the vaginal approach itself. As the procedure is performed without abdominal incisions, patients experience significantly less pain and require fewer or no painkillers post-operatively. The absence of external cuts also means no visible scarring, eliminating concerns around cosmesis and the risks of keloid formation and incisional hernias. These complications can be a real concern, especially for patients with obesity or have a tendency towards poor wound healing.
Recovery is notably faster compared to open surgery and comparable to laparoscopic approaches. This matters not just for patient comfort and independence, but a quicker recovery also means women with cancer can proceed to adjuvant treatments such as chemotherapy more promptly.
Taken together, the evidence strongly supports vNOTES as a superior option across multiple dimensions: safety, recovery, cosmetic outcomes and oncological efficacy. Where a patient is deemed suitable, it is our preferred approach.
Q: How does vNOTES fit into the management of gynaecological oncology cases at a medical centre?
Dr Ravichandran: KKH manages a high volume of gynaecological oncology cases in Singapore, and vNOTES has become an integral approach to our surgical care across this spectrum. A wide range of procedures are performed using this technique, including staging surgery for endometrial cancer and, in selected cases, ovarian cancer.
One of the strengths of vNOTES in this setting is its versatility across different patient groups. For younger women, the technique also allows for a more tailored approach, including the option to preserve the ovaries for fertility, where clinically appropriate.
By offering a minimally invasive route that does not compromise oncological outcomes, vNOTES fits naturally into a comprehensive gynaecological oncology programme – supporting surgical precision, and the broader goal of helping patients recover well and return to their daily lives as quickly as possible.
Q: What should clinicians know when considering a referral for vNOTES?
Dr Ravichandran: vNOTES has evolved considerably beyond its early applications. Previously, the technique was largely limited to benign procedures such as hysterectomy for small fibroids. Today, it is performed safely across a much broader range of conditions – both benign and malignant. This includes complex cases such as hysterectomy for large fibroids or endometriosis, myomectomy, ovarian cystectomy and the removal of fallopian tubes. At KKH, approximately 60 per cent of benign gynaecological procedures are now performed via vNOTES.
This technique is worth considering for any patient requiring a hysterectomy or other gynaecological surgery, regardless of whether the indication is benign or oncological. Women who may be particularly suitable include those with a higher BMI, a history of upper abdominal surgery or prior umbilical hernia repair. It is also beneficial to women who can benefit from a faster return to daily activities, or who need to commence adjuvant treatment promptly.
At KKH, suitability for vNOTES is determined through a thorough clinical assessment on a case-by-case basis. We encourage early referral for evaluation where possible, so that patients can be considered for this approach in a timely manner.
How vNOTES is being applied at KKH
Case Study 1: vNOTES for endometrial cancer in an elderly woman with multiple co-morbidities Mdm A in her 90s presented with increased per vaginal bleeding and was diagnosed with endometrial cancer. Given her advanced age and multiple co-morbidities involving heart conditions, stroke and dementia, treatment options including definitive surgical management were discussed. The family was hesitant to proceed in view of her age and medical complexity. Despite conservative management, Mdm A continued to experience persistent bleeding affecting her health and quality of life, causing anxiety to her family. vNOTES was offered during discussions with a gynaecological oncologist and Advanced Practice Nurse (APN), with explanation of its benefits and risks, pre-operative optimisation strategies and expected post-operative recovery. The family agreed to surgery utilising vNOTES by her primary gynaecological oncologist, and with care from a multidisciplinary team from Singapore General Hospital including a cardiologist, neurologist and anaesthetist, to concurrently manage her co-morbidities. Mdm A had an uneventful intraoperative course and recovered well post-operatively. |
Case Study 2: vNOTES for endometrial cancer in a woman with morbid obesity Mdm B in her 30s presented with abnormal uterine bleeding and was diagnosed with endometrial cancer. Treatment options were discussed, and she opted for definitive cancer treatment involving total hysterectomy. In view of her morbid obesity (BMI 60), careful consideration was needed for the surgical approach. A minimally invasive approach via vNOTES was offered, given its potential advantages in reducing abdominal wound complications in obese patients and lower cost compared to robotic surgery. The patient proceeded with the surgery after being counselled by APNs on the benefits, risks and technical challenges, particularly in the context of her body habitus. The surgery was uneventful and, post-operatively, she was closely monitored and safely discharged the following day. Mdm B made a good post-operative recovery, and weight management was advised as part of her long-term health plan. |
Case Study 3: vNOTES for multiple fibroids and cysts in a woman with intellectual disability Ms C in her 40s has intellectual disability, and an evaluation of a large pelvic mass was subsequently found to be secondary to multiple uterine fibroids and an ovarian cyst. During consultation, she could only provide limited symptom history due to communication difficulties. Her parents, both in their 70s, were her primary caregivers. Her mother experienced caregiver strain as she was also working and caring for her husband with mobility issues. The family was agreed to surgery using vNOTES involving total hysterectomy with bilateral salpingectomy, with counselling by an APN on associated risks and perioperative care. Findings from the surgery revealed a markedly enlarged uterus equivalent to a 28-week gestation size, with multiple fibroids where the largest was over 10cm. Ms C made a good recovery from her surgery with minimal discomfort expressed. This highlights the advantages of reduced post-operative pain and faster recovery, which helps to alleviate caregiver burden and facilitate smoother post-operative care in the community. |
Refer a patient Community healthcare professionals can refer a woman for assessment of their suitability for vNOTES with the Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology via the KKH Central Appointments Hotline at +65 6294 4050 or centralappt@kkh.com.sg (Mondays to Fridays, 8.00am to 5.30pm; Saturdays, 8.30am to 12.00pm; closed on Sundays and Public Holidays). For assessment specific to gynaecological oncology, queries can be made via +65 6394 8803 or GCC@kkh.com.sg (Mondays to Thursday, 8.30am to 6.00pm; Fridays: 8.30am to 5.30pm; closed on Saturdays, Sundays and Public Holidays). |
